NewsLocal NewsI-Team Investigations

Actions

FDOT paid contractors $8 million in bonuses as state road projects faced delays, budget increases

Delays on your commute are costing you money, time
Posted: 6:45 AM, May 13, 2019
Updated: 2019-05-14 03:15:29-04
Gandy Blvd. construction delayed

FDOT paid out more than $8 million in bonuses to road construction contractors in just one year, the I-Team uncovered.

Those bonuses — paid to contractors for finishing all or part of a job early or on schedule — come at a time when ABC Action News found most state road projects are delayed and over budget.

ABC Action News I-Team investigator Adam Walser found FDOT allowed contractors to add 15,050 days in added construction time — or about 41 years — to the latest Tampa Bay area road construction projects.

I-TEAM INVESTIGATIONS | Our latest investigations

FDOT rules allow the agency to fine contractors thousands of dollars a day for delays.

But those fines can wind up in drawn-out appeals and many road projects aren’t considered delayed under the state’s definition.

That’s because FDOT can extend the time span for a road project by granting contractors extra days for holidays, special events and bad weather.

An I-Team review found:

  • The state let the contractor for a major expansion of Gandy Boulevard in Pinellas County add 600 days to the estimated job completion time;
  • A contractor repaving a Polk County road got approved for 102 extra days;
  • And FDOT allowed a contractor repaving Citrus County U.S. Highway 19 to tack on 254 extra days —including 91 holidays — since work began in November 2016.

“I just think it’s dragging out way too long,” said Jim Long, a driver in Citrus County.

Hernando County resident Steve Rich, who owns a tree trimming business, said local road construction has him stuck in traffic.

“It can take an hour — sometimes 45 minutes — to get to a job just because of the delays,” said Rich.

ABC Action News also found the state granted the contractor paving U.S. Highway 19 in Hernando County 162 weather days — including 12 days in February 2018.

The I-Team asked our own expert — ABC Action News Meteorologist Denis Phillips — to check the weather those days and he only found it rained during four of those days.

FDOT said it called off work during the rest of those days because it was too cold to pave.

Temperatures soared into the 80s with unseasonably warm weather those days, but FDOT only allowed paving overnight when temperatures dropped below the 65-degree threshold for paving.

“They will not let us work on Friday before a holiday, if it’s on a Monday — it's a travel day — or the day following or the whole week,” said Tug Winthrop of Pepper Contracting, who wasn’t involved in any of the projects reviewed by the I-Team.

Winthrop, who has 25 years of experience with road projects, said most weather days approved by FDOT are valid but told ABC Action News he’s also seen some contractors abuse the system.

“There’s been other instances and abuses where it may not mean weather at all and it’s for something else,” said Winthrop. “It’s a potential issue that the industry’s concerned about.”

DRIVING TAMPA BAY FORWARD | Latest headlines on safety and infrastructure in our area

Brian McKishnie, operations manager for FDOT District 7 — which includes most state roads projects in the bay area, said his agency stands behind every approved extra day.

“Our project staff are the ones that monitor the weather conditions and if they meet the criteria for a weather day, they grant it to the contractor,” said McKishnie. “We shouldn’t be granting weather time when the conditions don't warrant it.”

Holidays and weather days added 34% more days on average to District 7 projects in the last fiscal year, the I-Team found.

McKishnie said there are good reasons FDOT bans contractors from working on certain days, such as Gasparilla, spring break or sports events.

“Those are days when we direct our contractor not to work to minimize the impact on the public,” said McKishnie.

But Winthrop said contractors and FDOT need to work together to speed up road projects.

“The public is getting weary of contracts that go on and on and on and aren’t finished in a timely fashion,” said Winthrop. “I think the state has an obligation to protect the taxpayer. That’s who really runs the show out here.”

If you have a story you’d like the I-Team to investigate, email adam@abcactionnews.com.