Stay Connected: RSS | Email Alerts | Mobile & iPhone
Print this Story
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large

Prescription Price Comparison Surprise


Last Update: 8/07/2009 6:20 pm
"At first I thought it was an error in their computer system!"
Reported by: John Matarese

Everyone knows generic prescriptions are cheaper than name brands. That's a no brainer: Ask for the generic, and save.

Unfortunately, that can lead to complacency, and paying higher prices than you need to.

Why is my Generic Medicine so Expensive?

When Tom Baldwin needed to fill a prescription, he went to the drugstore his mom used for decades...Walgreens.

"I used our family pharmacy that we have been using for 20, 30...20 years," Tom told me.

So he was surprised when their "family pharmacy" charged them $136 for a bottle of Gabapentin, a generic anti seizure medication.  The Baldwins assumed since it was a generic, it would cost much less.

Tom's mother Barbara told me "at first I thought it was an error in their computer system." 

But it wasn't an error. They were even more stunned when they checked the pharmacy at a nearby Costco, after a recommendation from a relative.  Tom says  "I decided to call Costco to get a price and it was $15 and some cents, 90 cents I think, and I couldn't believe it!"

The receipt from their next order of medication shows the difference: the Baldwins were charged $136.49 at Walgreens, $15.79 at Costco just a few weeks later.

Tom says "it was the same number of pills, same size, same strength, same medication."

Comparing the Pharmacies

So we did a price check for 120 pills of 300 miligram Gabapentin.

  • Two Walgreens quoted us $136, the same Tom paid.
  • Drugstore.com, a popular mail order pharmacy, was $71.
  • A supermarket pharmacy -- Kroger -- quoted us $56.
  • And Costco was just $15.
Next: A fluke? What national surveys found.
More Taking Action for You
Social Security check goes missing
This retiree got by okay on social security, until Uncle Sam misplaced his check. Video Video
Toyota dealerships make plans for repairs
One week after an unprecedented recall related to sticky gas pedals, the world's largest automaker says it has identified a solution. Video Video
Consumer Reports: Energy Star label might not be deserved
If you are looking for an appliance that is going to save energy, you might not find the combination easy to find, according to Consumer Reports' tests. Video Video
Soldier receives long awaited delivery
The custom bike took a year to build, but finally made its way cross country to an awaiting soldier. Video Video
New fridge causes headaches
She picked out a new fridge, but the service calls started soon after. Video Video


  This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.